This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site you consent to our use of cookies. Close

Africa Legal

Africa Legal

  • NEWS
  • JOBS
  • COURSES
  • CLIENTS
    • Sign in
    • Sign up
  • NEWS
  • COURSES
  • JOBS
    • Sign In
    • Sign Up
  • News
  • Courses
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Business A-Z
  • Post a job
  • Contact Us
  • Clients
CLIENT SIGN IN
Country
  • Uganda
  • South Africa
  • Kenya
  • Nigeria
  • Cameroon
  • United Kingdom
  • Cote d'Ivoire
  • Ghana
  • Tanzania
  • Zambia
  • Botswana
  • Morocco
  • Zimbabwe
  • Mauritius
  • Mozambique
  • Sudan
  • Rwanda
  • Ethiopia
  • Angola
  • Egypt
  • Togo
  • Mali
  • South Sudan
  • Swaziland
  • Senegal
  • Malawi
  • France
  • Guinea
  • Middle East
  • Democratic Republic of the Congo
  • Gambia
  • Sierra Leone
  • Germany
Category
  • Profiles
  • Analysis & Opinion
  • Career advice
  • In-house
  • Latest news
  • Press releases
  • Africa Legal Blog
  • Women in Law
  • Innovation
  • Human Rights
Practice area
  • Agriculture
  • Arbitration
  • Aviation
  • Banking and Finance
  • Capital markets
  • Charties and pro bono
  • Company commercial
  • Competition and antitrust
  • Construction and engineering
  • Consumer products
  • Corporate finance and M&A
  • Criminal
  • Education
  • Employment and benefits
  • Energy and natural resources
  • Environmental
  • Financial services
  • Fraud & white collar crime
  • Funds
  • Governance | risk and compliance
  • Government and public sector
  • Health and safety
  • Healthcare and pharmaceuticals
  • Insurance/Reinsurance
  • Intellectual Property
  • Litigation and dispute resolution
  • Logistics and transportation
  • Manufacturing and Industrial
  • Private client and family
  • Private equity
  • Projects and infrastructure
  • Real estate
  • Regulatory
  • Restructuring | insolvency and debt recovery
  • Shipping and maritime
  • Taxation
  • Technology media and telecoms
  • Travel and tourism
close

Registration

Registered Successfully!!!. We have sent you a confirmation email to your email address.
close


View My Saved News


close You must login to save your news
  • LOGIN
  • NEW USER

Login to your account

Forgotten your password?
or

Create an Account

close


View My Saved News


« Back

Silent Water Theft by Trees

Planting trees is often seen as a perfect solution to many environmental problems. Not so, say lawyers in a high-profile court case that has highlighted the negative impacts of expanding tree plantations in water-scarce African nations, writes Tony Carnie.

Mar 25, 2021
Tony Carnie
Share

The South African government has gone to court to defend its water conservation laws by opposing an unregulated tree species swop-over in the world’s 30th driest nation.

Commercial timber farmers, represented by Forestry South Africa, launched a civil case against the national water minister and water tribunal two years ago to enable tree planters to convert many of their existing plantations from pine trees to eucalyptus (gum) trees in order to cash in on rising global demand for clothes and textiles made from gum tree-based cellulose fibres.

While the idea of switching from one type of tree species to another might not seem such a big deal from a legal perspective, senior water and forestry scientists note that gum trees can use vastly more water than pine trees – anywhere between 25% to 45% more water, according to hydrology expert Professor Graham Jewitt from the IHE Delft Institute for Water Education in the Netherlands

Forestry South Africa has sought to persuade High Court judge Selwyn Hockey that there should be no legal obstacle to the species switchover for growers who hold existing permits or licences, but Jewitt and State Attorney Msubanzi Sisilana insist that allowing an uncontrolled or unregulated species swop-over could lead to future water shortages and potentially “devastating impacts” on stream-water flow in many areas – especially during droughts.

This was because once trees were in the ground there was no way of stopping them from sucking water from the ground for several years – other than chopping them down.

As a result, if timber farmers wanted to switch from pine to gum trees for commercial gain, the area of planted land should be reduced accordingly to compensate for the additional water use.

Forestry South Africa has argued that the water-use impacts of gum trees are potentially over-estimated by computer models developed by expert hydrology studies and that the industry should not be impeded from switching to gum.

But the government argues that the commercial imperatives of the timber industry cannot over-ride the need to ensure sustainable water supplies for people, other downstream farmers, industries and the ecology – also noting that the case could have far-reaching impacts on South Africa’s water conservation laws and policies.

If the court accepted the position of the forestry industry “the entire basis for the allocation of water use licences under the 1998 National Water Act will be under threat,” the water ministry argued.

Judgment has been reserved.


To join Africa Legal's mailing list please click here 

Copyright : Re-publication of this article is authorised only in the following circumstances; the writer and Africa Legal are both recognised as the author and the website address www.africa-legal.com and original article link are back linked. A bio for the writer can be provided on request.

RELATED CATEGORY NEWS

Using tech to restore land rights in T Read more
Sentence upheld for Kenya university a Read more
Curbing the extraction of “conflict mi Read more

RELATED COUNTRY NEWS

Evolving to suit clients Read more
Moving up: From security guard to trai Read more
“Patent abuse” challenged in South Afr Read more
Africa Legal
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy and cookies policy
Members
  • Find a job
  • Take a course
  • Read news
  • Terms and conditions
  • Cancellations and refunds
Clients
  • Terms and conditions
  • Post a job
  • Host a course
  • Advertise
  • Share news
Connect with us
© Copyright 2023 | Africa Legal. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy