This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site you consent to our use of cookies. Close

Africa Legal

Africa Legal

  • NEWS
  • JOBS
  • COURSES
  • CLIENTS
    • Sign in
    • Sign up
  • NEWS
  • COURSES
  • JOBS
    • Sign In
    • Sign Up
  • News
  • Courses
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Business A-Z
  • Post a job
  • Contact Us
  • Clients
CLIENT SIGN IN
Country
  • Uganda
  • South Africa
  • Kenya
  • Nigeria
  • Cameroon
  • United Kingdom
  • Cote d'Ivoire
  • Ghana
  • Tanzania
  • Zambia
  • Botswana
  • Morocco
  • Zimbabwe
  • Mauritius
  • Mozambique
  • Sudan
  • Rwanda
  • Ethiopia
  • Angola
  • Egypt
  • Togo
  • Mali
  • South Sudan
  • Swaziland
  • Senegal
  • Malawi
  • France
  • Guinea
  • Middle East
  • Democratic Republic of the Congo
  • Gambia
  • Sierra Leone
  • Germany
Category
  • Profiles
  • Analysis & Opinion
  • Career advice
  • In-house
  • Latest news
  • Press releases
  • Africa Legal Blog
  • Women in Law
  • Innovation
  • Human Rights
Practice area
  • Agriculture
  • Arbitration
  • Aviation
  • Banking and Finance
  • Capital markets
  • Charties and pro bono
  • Company commercial
  • Competition and antitrust
  • Construction and engineering
  • Consumer products
  • Corporate finance and M&A
  • Criminal
  • Education
  • Employment and benefits
  • Energy and natural resources
  • Environmental
  • Financial services
  • Fraud & white collar crime
  • Funds
  • Governance | risk and compliance
  • Government and public sector
  • Health and safety
  • Healthcare and pharmaceuticals
  • Insurance/Reinsurance
  • Intellectual Property
  • Litigation and dispute resolution
  • Logistics and transportation
  • Manufacturing and Industrial
  • Private client and family
  • Private equity
  • Projects and infrastructure
  • Real estate
  • Regulatory
  • Restructuring | insolvency and debt recovery
  • Shipping and maritime
  • Taxation
  • Technology media and telecoms
  • Travel and tourism
close

Registration

Registered Successfully!!!. We have sent you a confirmation email to your email address.
close


View My Saved News


close You must login to save your news
  • LOGIN
  • NEW USER

Login to your account

Forgotten your password?
or

Create an Account

close


View My Saved News


« Back

Plan to bar lawyers from environmental appeals

Attorneys in South Africa have objected to law change proposals which they believe could bar them from representing poor communities and activists who challenge environmental decisions by government, reports Tony Carnie.

Feb 14, 2022
Tony Carnie
Share

South African environment minister Barbara Creecy

While most attorneys were enjoying the Christmas holidays, South African environment minister Barbara Creecy published a seemingly innocuous notice in the government gazette about plans to amend sections of the National Environmental Management Act (NEMA).

On the face of it, the amendments refer to the registration of environmental assessment practitioners (EAPs). But several attorneys are worried that the proposals are poorly framed and will effectively exclude them from appeal proceedings in terms of Section 43 of NEMA.

Jeremy Ridl, a senior environmental attorney and planning law specialist, has submitted a formal objection arguing that the proposed regulations will appropriate work to EAPs that is reserved to legal practitioners – and that this is unlawful. Ridl said the exclusion of lawyers from such environmental processes was inconsistent with the provisions of NEMA, which were clearly designed to make environmental justice, through the courts, more accessible to vulnerable communities.

He believed the amendments have far-reaching implications for vulnerable communities, especially those who rely on pro bono legal services. The publication of the changes on December 31 also seemed to be a disingenuous attempt to “slip legislation through” while lawyers and other stakeholders were on holiday.

Minister Creecy had failed to provide any explanation on the need to limit the rights of communities to proper representation, especially in environmental processes that were more about law than they were about environmental management.

Ridl said the law changes also came at a time when communities had achieved some notable successes in court in challenging environmental authorisations issued by the Department of Mineral Resources or in setting aside flawed appeal decisions made by Minister Creecy and her provincial counterparts. 

Janice Tooley, an environmental attorney and director of the All Rise non-profit law clinic in Durban, believes the law changes could have “chilling effects” on Section 43 appeals. “We would like to mention upfront that the rationale for many of these Intended amendments is not obvious and thus it is difficult, if not impossible to be in a position to properly comment on them,” she said. “It is regrettable that the Department did not see fit to issue an accompanying memorandum that explains the reasons for the minister’s proposed changes.” 

Tooley questioned why the minister was seeking not only to create a role for EAPs in the appeal process, but also in so doing, making their role mandatory “to the point of excluding any other specialist and legal representation”. 

Dr Jenny Hall, a senior law lecturer at the University of Johannesburg, said that for nearly 20 years members of the public had enjoyed the right to participate in environmental decisions. Some of the proposed changes were therefore “an enormous intrusion and encroachment on this right and, with respect, a step backwards for democratic environmental governance”.

Environmental attorney Adrian Pole has suggested that the current wording of the law amendments is so wide and vague that it gives rise to significant legal uncertainty. It was difficult to imagine that it was the minister’s intention to undermine public participation in this manner, he commented, but if so, Pole said the amendments would be vulnerable to being challenged and set aside on High Court Review.


To join Africa Legal's mailing list please click here

Copyright : Re-publication of this article is authorised only in the following circumstances; the writer and Africa Legal are both recognised as the author and the website address www.africa-legal.com and original article link are back linked. A bio for the writer can be provided on request.

RELATED CATEGORY NEWS

Landmark ruling on matrimonial rights Read more
Citizen activists on trial in DRC Read more
Hogan Lovells bolsters SA practice Read more

RELATED COUNTRY NEWS

Two years of WMN striding ahead Read more
Niche firms with elephant-sized impact Read more
Custodians of risk and reward Read more
Africa Legal
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy and cookies policy
Members
  • Find a job
  • Take a course
  • Read news
  • Terms and conditions
  • Cancellations and refunds
Clients
  • Terms and conditions
  • Post a job
  • Host a course
  • Advertise
  • Share news
Connect with us
© Copyright 2023 | Africa Legal. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy