This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site you consent to our use of cookies. Close

Africa Legal

Africa Legal

  • NEWS
  • JOBS
  • COURSES
  • CLIENTS
    • Sign in
    • Sign up
  • NEWS
  • COURSES
  • JOBS
    • Sign In
    • Sign Up
  • News
  • Courses
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Business A-Z
  • Post a job
  • Contact Us
  • Clients
CLIENT SIGN IN
Country
  • Uganda
  • South Africa
  • Kenya
  • Nigeria
  • Cameroon
  • United Kingdom
  • Cote d'Ivoire
  • Ghana
  • Tanzania
  • Zambia
  • Botswana
  • Morocco
  • Zimbabwe
  • Mauritius
  • Mozambique
  • Sudan
  • Rwanda
  • Ethiopia
  • Angola
  • Egypt
  • Togo
  • Mali
  • South Sudan
  • Swaziland
  • Senegal
  • Malawi
  • France
  • Guinea
  • Middle East
  • Democratic Republic of the Congo
  • Gambia
  • Sierra Leone
  • Germany
Category
  • Profiles
  • Analysis & Opinion
  • Career advice
  • In-house
  • Latest news
  • Press releases
  • Africa Legal Blog
  • Women in Law
  • Innovation
  • Human Rights
Practice area
  • Agriculture
  • Arbitration
  • Aviation
  • Banking and Finance
  • Capital markets
  • Charties and pro bono
  • Company commercial
  • Competition and antitrust
  • Construction and engineering
  • Consumer products
  • Corporate finance and M&A
  • Criminal
  • Education
  • Employment and benefits
  • Energy and natural resources
  • Environmental
  • Financial services
  • Fraud & white collar crime
  • Funds
  • Governance | risk and compliance
  • Government and public sector
  • Health and safety
  • Healthcare and pharmaceuticals
  • Insurance/Reinsurance
  • Intellectual Property
  • Litigation and dispute resolution
  • Logistics and transportation
  • Manufacturing and Industrial
  • Private client and family
  • Private equity
  • Projects and infrastructure
  • Real estate
  • Regulatory
  • Restructuring | insolvency and debt recovery
  • Shipping and maritime
  • Taxation
  • Technology media and telecoms
  • Travel and tourism
close

Registration

Registered Successfully!!!. We have sent you a confirmation email to your email address.
close


View My Saved News


close You must login to save your news
  • LOGIN
  • NEW USER

Login to your account

Forgotten your password?
or

Create an Account

close


View My Saved News


« Back

Law, Ethics and the lawyer

South African jurist Dr JJ van der Walt reflects on whether it is more important to act with humanity than to pursue your legal right during this exceptional time.

May 26, 2020
Dr JJ van der Walt
Share

It is irrefutable that Covid-19 has brought the entire world to its knees - economically, socially, politically, and even religiously. In the legal context, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa “... appeal[ed] to all large businesses not to resort to force majeure and stop paying their suppliers and rental commitments…”.

The President, therefore, asked large businesses not to rely on force majeure clauses. This means, simply put, relying on 'the impossibility of performing' to either end or suspend a contractual obligation to perform.

The lawyer in me understands what Covid-19 means legally speaking. However, being more than a lawyer, the ethical scholar wants to pose the following question: Ought the (positive) law be disregarded in favour of, or changed to accommodate, the needs of human beings, especially in circumstances as current?

The President's statement was made because the law allows one to ‘escape’ the obligation to perform, even when you can perform, in circumstances where the other party cannot, which would normally be the position when one's obligation is payment. Is this an example where the law provides for a legal rule, but not necessarily a just rule? Something to think about, I hope...

An ethical understanding of the entire situation would enjoin acknowledgement and recognition of the being of a human as a human (which starts with one's existence in a relationship with others - ie an existential relationship) before recognising contractual obligations (ie a legal relationship).

While appreciating that everyone is affected by Covid-19, not everyone is affected equally (in the same manner or extent). It is this inequality (of impact) that the law does not take into account, which the President, by making his statement, acknowledged and confirmed, whether intentionally or not.

The final question that remains is: What does this mean or entail? I shall not pretend to understand everyone's unique circumstances, which means that there is no simple answer (or then solution).

I shall only note that when one has regard for the being of a human as a human, one would hope that regard is had, first, for basic sustenance (of the other) and, only thereafter, notions of increased profits and positive growth safeguarded by time immemorial maxims such as force majeure and vis major.

Thus, instead of ending contractual relationships that affect human relationships far more severely, perhaps we ought to, where sensible, sustain contractual relationships (through temporary compromise, for example) only to proceed where we left things before the pandemic. If we decide to do so, we would, in turn, sustain ourselves, which includes the self and the other.

Turning back to the lawyer in me, businesses and legal practitioners must come together and develop innovative methods of implementing negotiated legal structures within, and mechanisms through, which all the parties involved are positioned towards, and ultimately succeeds in, flourishing in a world after Covid-19.

 

To join Africa Legal's mailing list please click here 



Copyright : Re-publication of this article is authorised only in the following circumstances; the writer and Africa Legal are both recognised as the author and the website address www.africa-legal.com and original article link are back linked. A bio for the writer can be provided on request.

RELATED CATEGORY NEWS

Niche firms with elephant-sized impact Read more
Custodians of risk and reward Read more
An insightful look at competition, tra Read more

RELATED COUNTRY NEWS

Hogan Lovells bolsters SA practice Read more
Two years of WMN striding ahead Read more
Transforming the global future Read more
Africa Legal
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy and cookies policy
Members
  • Find a job
  • Take a course
  • Read news
  • Terms and conditions
  • Cancellations and refunds
Clients
  • Terms and conditions
  • Post a job
  • Host a course
  • Advertise
  • Share news
Connect with us
© Copyright 2023 | Africa Legal. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy